| Platinum | Cafe Jordano |
| Platinum | Nicolo's Chicago Style Pizza |
| Gold | Pizza Pizza Pasta Vila |
| Silver | Garramone's Pizza and Italian Restaurant |
| Bronze | Carmine's Deli |
| Top Pick | Bono's Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Deli Italia |
| Top Pick | Lechuga's Italian |
| Top Pick | Venice Ristorante & Wine Bar |